Elisha Cuthbert, Then and Now

Elisha Cuthbert Is in a Bikini and on a “Fat List”

Elisha-Cuthbert-Is-in-a-Bikini-and-on-a-Fat-List - Elisha Cuthbert Is in a Bikini and on a "Fat List"

A while back, I was quite sad to see Elisha on New York Post’s “50 Fat celebrities” list – see it here! I don’t like the idea of such a list anyway, but some of their choices were quite debatable:  Jessica Simpson and Rachel Hunter were also on this “Fat List”.

Elisha is not as slender as she was a few years ago when she did “Girl Next Door”, meaning like this:

elisha-cuthbert-weight-gain - Elisha Cuthbert Is in a Bikini and on a "Fat List"

… but she gained weight quite proportionally all over and gained some curves in the process too, so is it OK to place her on a “Fat List”?

See much more pictures after the jump!

Elisha-Cuthbert-Is-in-a-Bikini-and-on-a-Fat-List-3 - Elisha Cuthbert Is in a Bikini and on a "Fat List"

Elisha-Cuthbert-Is-in-a-Bikini-and-on-a-Fat-List-4 - Elisha Cuthbert Is in a Bikini and on a "Fat List"

Elisha-Cuthbert-Is-in-a-Bikini-and-on-a-Fat-List-5 - Elisha Cuthbert Is in a Bikini and on a "Fat List"

Elisha-Cuthbert-Is-in-a-Bikini-and-on-a-Fat-List-6 - Elisha Cuthbert Is in a Bikini and on a "Fat List"

elisha-cuthbert-bikini-1-08 - Elisha Cuthbert Is in a Bikini and on a "Fat List"

Elisha-Cuthbert-Is-in-a-Bikini-and-on-a-Fat-List-2 - Elisha Cuthbert Is in a Bikini and on a "Fat List"

Incoming search terms:

elisha cuthbert height, elisha cuthbert fat, elisha cuthbert weight, how tall is elisha cuthbert, elisha cuthbert weight gain, elisha cuthbert measurements, elisha cuthbert height and weight, elisha cuthbert Bikini, elisha cuthbert height weight, elisha cuthbert gained weight
Previous ArticleNext Article
Editor of Skinny vs Curvy Website

119
Leave a Reply

avatar
81 Comment threads
38 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
103 Comment authors
AnaShane LambertSarahbuythesisLukeTheDuke Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Ellie
Member

Obviously she looked better before, but NO WAY does she belong on a fat list. I highly doubt the people that put together that list would appreciate their weight fluctuations being flaunted in front of everyone. Weight gain happens. She’ll get it together.

Hydrangea
Guest
Hydrangea

I wouldn’t say fat. More like chubby. And her weight gain isn’t an unattractive gain imo. She gained quite proportionally and she looks lovely. Albeit, I prefer her more slender image.

buythesis
Guest

true that

lalalala
Guest
lalalala

WOW that is so ridiculous!!! i don’t even know what to say!!

nessa
Guest
nessa

shes curvy and NORMAL! we are so used to seeing unhealthy skinny we forget what normal sized people..not just women..but PEOPLE in general look like

K
Guest
K

I agree. She’s a normal woman it makes me sick people forget what regular is!!!! I’m sure she is healthy! It’s horrible to call someone like her fat..she is curvy and beautiful.

Sharen
Guest
Sharen

yeah, she is normal, but she was also normal and healthy looking before, actually, she looked more healthy before, her legs are pretty untoned now.

I’m surprised that everybody thinks that this is the normal size to be. I don’t know where you guys live, but where I live people come in all different sizes.

MB
Guest
MB

To those who are saying they preferred her more slender image, would you say the same thing if you knew she had to practically starve herself to get the slender physique? I’m not saying that’s what she did, but from personal experience, I can safely say that a very strict, restricted diet was most likely the reason she got to such a slender size – and the reason she couldn’t maintain it.

missy
Guest
missy

I have to disagree on this one… Not saying she didn’t starve herself before, but Im willing to bet she just doesn’t work out. If she did (watched what she ate), she’d have no problem staying that size. She wasn’t a stick before.
That being said, she isn’t fat and I empathize with her because I have going on.. the only thing remotely thick on her is her thighs, and they make her look bigger than she is. The rest of her body is NOT big.

Cecil
Guest
Cecil

you can still starve yourself and not be stick thin, it’s all about metabolism. And she was still really thin before. Her body might naturally become as thick as it is above when she eats correctly… or she could just not be eating as well. She looks healthy in both pictures, but that doesn’t mean she is healthy in either, or unhealthy. You don’t know her in real life to make that judgement.

safa
Guest
safa

yes, you’re right! I’m a doctor specializing in endocrinology, diabetes and nutrition; and I believe that a weight control is based on both a healthy eating and regular exercise. YOU DO NOT NEED to starve yourself to be in a good shape! you need to know how to do it slowly but surely. Now, I don’t thing she’s obese, but she is might be overweight which is exposing her to some health issues including gaining more weight!!!! so It has to stop! And ladies, you’d better get moving and watch what you eat! a healthy weight is a key word… Read more »

kate
Guest
kate

Yeah right, you’re a doctor……….

Why do people make sh*t up on here. Doctors do not sit around on gossip sites LOL.

suzushii
Guest
suzushii

Even doctors like trivial, superficial things. They’re not androgynous Spocks only concerned with scholarly studies :P.

safa
Guest
safa

this is weired! why do you feel like you’re doing something only stupid and pointless people would do???????? some doctors like to play golf, others especially at 25 Y old like to do what they were missing for the last 8 years!!!!!!!!!! and YES I’m a young doctor! BIG TIME
I(ve been working so hard since high school!! I deserve to have fun in My way!

Jo
Guest
Jo

My brother is a doctor and even had a fully paid scholarship to med school, and he spends every available time he has playing World of Warcraft or Grand Theft Auto. Doctors are humans too and have hobbies just like us.

amazon
Guest
amazon

this girl is NOT medically overweight, actually she looks exactly like I looked in my last hol pics, i am even a short blonde. MY bMI IS AROUND 20. THAT IS NOT OVERWEIGHT. IF YOU ARE A DOCTOR SPECIALISING IN THIS SORT OF THING, YOU SHOULD BE ABLE TO SPOT THAT.

Sydney
Guest
Sydney

BMI is not the only thing that determines whether your are “medically overweight.” Your weight might be proportionate to your height (a BMI of 20 for example), but your fat to lean muscle mass percentage might be in the overweight or even obese range–aka “skinny fat.” Elisha Cuthbert might have a normal BMI, but from these pictures, it looks like her body fat % is in the overweight range.

Miranda
Guest
Miranda

I doubt she was starving herself before. That movie was made 6 years ago, she was younger and probably had a much faster metabolism them. As people age, their metabolism slows down but they tend to keep eating the same, so it’s not unusual for someone who was naturally thin to suddenly gain weight without changing their diet.

And since she’d just started getting work and recognition, she probably had a personal trainer.

violet
Guest
violet

a FAT list? that is disgusting. i’ve just gone through the list and while the vast majority are very overweight that’s no excuse, it’s just a horrible thing to do. however Jessica Simpson, Danielle Fishel and Elisha Cuthbert stick out like a sore thumb. so none of them are size 0 or 2 but they all have normal healthy looking bodies.

Biz
Guest
Biz

agreed. ‘Fat Lists’ are nothing but a contributor to unhealthy body image and poor eating habits. Makes me feel bad for women.

southerngumdrops
Guest
southerngumdrops

agreed. i also wonder how thin these women look in person (the camera adds lbs)….for example, lauren conrad looks to be of a normal weight on tv but when i saw her at a book signing i was shocked at how teeny tiny she was

this list does nothing to improve women’s already screwed up body image….disgusting

Evie
Member

Yeah, the idea of a “fat list” is very mean!
And those women are in no way even comparable to the other names on the list, so pointless!

madeleine
Guest
madeleine

she is definitely chubby…on my standards yes i would consider her fat. But she does NOT belong on such a list…neither does jessica? she looked really good a couple of days ago in those shorts…i’d say the body she had before would be hard for her to maintain as well

Ellia
Guest
Ellia

Let me guess…the list was comprised of either ALL or predominately women??

such a bloody double standard.

jenna
Guest
jenna

unfortunately, no. because there are many more fat male celebrities than female because being a fat female celebrity is much more frowned upon… for males it’s just more to love. such crap!

blake
Guest
blake

FAT list- what a twisted, sick idea… and elisha, jessica, Missy Elliot on it?? abnormal and disturbing…

and to elisha´s body- ok, she gained, but she is nowhere near fat, she just put on a few- these things happen. she looked good before, she looks good now with the only difference that now she looks like a normal average woman, not like a walking perfection.. so what? her body, her choice… and calling her fat is just… it sickens me..

Lovisa
Member

no way she is fat!!!

Lana
Guest
Lana

that is UNBELIEVABLE. just because you arent stick thin doesnt mean you are fat. shes prob only a size 12 uk (6 us) and that is so unsulting to normal girls who look like that. the media need to be more careful about the negative ideas that they are trying to put into the heads of young people. it’s irresponsable and i am beyond DISGUSTED

Sharen
Guest
Sharen

If a US 6 is European 38, there is no way her legs fit into that.

Minnie
Guest
Minnie

A size 12 UK is a size 8 US. Not far off, but I wanted to clarify…
I’m a size 0 US and I always buy a size 4 UK.

Boris
Member

how is your size relevent to anything?

Nkeon
Guest
Nkeon

I believe she was using it as an example to explain the UK/US equivelant in sizes i.e. there is a difference in 4 between the sizes

anon
Guest
anon

Gosh I’ve just looked at the fat list. That is awful!!! Why did they feel the need to create such a list!?! I’d love for the people that compose such lists/make nasty comments to have their pictures put up because they must be perfect. I’d love to see what perfect looks like. She’s so not fat. Yes she looks to have gained, but then when was that picture taken?? 5 years ago??? A lot of peoples weight will change over time. As many have mentioned I would say she’s a normal size. Not fat, not over weight, not chubby, not… Read more »

Debbie
Guest
Debbie

Her body is banging. Beautiful curves. Not fat.

Allie
Guest
Allie

Yes, she definitely does belong there.

Leah
Guest
Leah

agreed..

Lia
Guest
Lia

What a joke.
This is the reason why people get issues with their appearances.

Femca
Guest
Femca

Yes, I can imagine people getting isues with their bodies because of something like this too. Speaking for myself, I think my body is almost exactly like hers… So how nice te hear that she’s on a fat list!!!

BlackEssence
Guest
BlackEssence

Nothing wrong with that woman’s body.

Sidney
Guest
Sidney

Gosh she’s nowhere near fat, and the list is disgusting, some women, and men, don’t mind the word fat, but in this context it’s clearly used as an insult.

rachel from glee
Guest

shes fine either way. looks good to me.

beckers!
Guest
beckers!

The weight gain doesn’t look bad, iv gained as much as she has yet sadly not as proportionately.

dsfsdf
Guest
dsfsdf

How retarded… she looks better than ever…muh better with meat like everybody…

Mizzy
Guest
Mizzy

yeah, she gained weight, but she actually has a REALLY cute body at this weight! Most women are not lucky enough to look like this with extra weight…I think she should stay at this weight, she is more attractive now.
as for a fat list, if such a thing even needs to exist, should be limited to only people who are obese (and I mean by medical standards). it is just offensive to put women like ELisha and Jessica Simpson, who are clearly at a healthy weight, just not hollywood thin!

Julchen
Guest
Julchen

wow…what a crazy world… I mean, who the hell creates a “FAT LIST”?!?!? that’s tasteless…

mEEEE
Guest
mEEEE

It’s just sad that a “normal-sized” body would make it on a Hollywood fat list. I also agree with another poster, if the weight gain is that drastic (by Hollywood standards) thats probably because she had to go through drastic measures to achieve it.

mermaid
Guest
mermaid

oh, please! this woman is NOT fat…and a fat list should NOT exist. let me start by saying i CANONT stand elisha cuthbert (her attitude, i think her face looks like miss piggy, her hair is s—ky and i think she is cheap, especially with all her hockey drama), so i obviously feel strongly about this, if i come to her defense. her body is still great! she has bigger thighs than some of us would like – but look at her shape – it is still there! i actually think this body is just as nice – but different… Read more »

Lo
Guest
Lo

WOW. She’s fat? Really? That’s ridiculous. Just because she gained weight does not mean she’s fat. I wouldn’t even call her chubby. She has a softer look now, yes, but she still looks great in my eyes. If she’s comfortable, happy, and healthy at the weight she’s at, then I think that’s all that matters. For those of you that truly think she belongs on that list, or that a list like that should even exist, go get a reality check.

Michelle DD
Guest
Michelle DD

shes definitely too fat for her height and frame

Lisa
Guest
Lisa

I know celebrity culture is shallow in general, but the idea of a fat list is so damaging. Some of them ARE overweight, yes (and I was surprised to see them include men!), but don’t you think they know that already? Including people like Elisha is ridiculous. Then they’ll be the first to congratulate her when she drops the weight, then cry crocodile tears when she takes it a little too far. And they’ll act like they have no idea how this could have happened, what would have given her the idea she needed to lose. She has gained weight,… Read more »

artemis
Guest
artemis

except for the belly and thigh she’s not heavy

summerrain88
Guest
summerrain88

This just goes to show messed up Hollywood is when someone that’s completely healthy-looking and normal sized is called “fat”. She’s obviously bigger than she was in the older picture, but I think she looks good in both. She wasn’t sickeningly skinny in the old picture, but I’m guessing she’s like Jessica Simpson at her Daisy Duke size. They both looked more toned and slim at those weights, but (at least for Jessica by her own admission) it was likely very difficult to get there and maintain those shapes without a severely restrictive diet and a grueling work-out regime. Just… Read more »

Leila
Guest
Leila

She is not fat, she looks pretty average, like many other woman I see on the beach during vacation. But I myself wouldn’t feel comfortable with this body. Discipline is one of my most important values in life, and it is not always easy to resist while others do and eat whatever they want. But when I look at these pictures I know that it is worth it. Not that she looks bad now, but she could look so much better if she wanted to

mermaid
Guest
mermaid

oh really? how do you know she is eating whatever she wants? i am really glad you are disciplined and it makes you happy. i am glad you are ‘healthy’ and feel good about your body and all. but let me tell you, i think she looked great before (still don’t like her or her face) and i still think she looks great (but different) now. and plenty of guys like her either way. and many would actually, honestly prefer her like this. so to me, its not ‘worth it’ to be OVERLY restrictive, when you can still look great.… Read more »

Casey
Guest
Casey

She is not fat, period. Chubby, gained weight, etc, maybe, but not fat. As for the fat list, I’m not even sure what to say about it. I haven’t looked it at it but I’m willing to bet it was designed more to garner traffic and less to “hurt” the celebrities or make fun of fat people. And as for her body, she seem to have let herself go. She used to have a body that I envied, but now, I see nothing enviable about it. It’s not even just the weight gain. Look at Britney.She gained weight but has… Read more »

Guest
sara

Versus i think you might find this interesting, crystal renn walked chanel today http://www.zimbio.com/Crystal+Renn/articles/MgEUqmIZDEh/Crystal+Renn+Walks+Chanel+2011+Cruise+Collection

southerngumdrops
Guest
southerngumdrops

oooo! LOVE

cat
Guest
cat

a better pic i suppose. she looks normal sized here. in fact she looks rather thin. she’s gorgeous. i’m so jealous of the fact that even when she’s at a heavier weight, her face is thin with prominent cheekbones.

comment image

van
Guest
van

This is the most outrageous thing I’ve heard as of late.

Has anyone seen this list yet? IT’S RIDICULOUS. It has older stars (including some deceased) and randomly throws in Elisha, Clay Aiken, etc. I really don’t understand. Yes, she has gained weight but she looks like anyone else on the street. She looks normal, average, whatever you’d like to call it. Weight gains happens and considering how she looked probably less than a year ago, it’ll eventually fluctuate down again. This is the worst thing to see, that fat list needs to stop.

lc
Guest
lc

Hmmm…Fat? Not really. But by no means is it an enviable body, imo. That list is a bit degrading.

Brittany
Guest
Brittany

She obviously has quite a bit of fat on her so, yes. But fat as in “plus size” or over weight, no

Padme
Guest
Padme

The real question here is is it ok to make a fat list? Absolutely not! This reminds of something 12 year old boys would do. It’s pathetic, immature, and extremely mentally damging to everyone (both the people on the list and those who have seen the list).

Léa
Guest
Léa

Exactly !

Why I was at school, those boys made a list about what they thought were the most ugly girls in the school. And they were 14.

A fat list is absolutely why stupid, immature children would do

jenna
Guest
jenna

i don’t see the point in making a fat list… but she could lose some weight. (not saying that the weight gain may not be completely natural.)

Max
Guest
Max

Oh god, she was hot in The Girl Next Door. But, whoa she does look fat. Her thighs looks so LUMPY & the fat and cellulite are BULGING out of her skin. Her b❆❆bs got bigger, yay! But, they don’t make up for the fatness everywhere else. Elisha: it is POOL season, GET IT TOGETHER!!

madeleine
Guest
madeleine

my guess is you’re a girl who’s very insecure about her weight..so much so that you feel the need to come on here and write on every post how every woman over the size of a 2 is disgusting…deal with your psychological problems elsewhere…

machmalow
Guest
machmalow

ow that’s a shame she looked hot before, but I mean calling her fat now … common.. There’s some work to do on the thighs, but overall she’s quite proportionate isn’t she ?

kate
Guest
kate

Yes, she’s gained some weight. Yes she’s a bit chubby in places. Does she look unhealthy? No. Doe sshe belong on that godawful list? Hell no!

skirmute
Guest

People who put her on this list are totally insane! Fat? Where is she fat? Just because she has fuller thighs? For a normal woman having bigger thighs is absolutely fine.
Look at her waist, it’s still small. That is a normal, feminine figure.

Freedom
Member
Freedom

(0).(o) wOw the publisher obviously made a mistake. I am one for fit and svelte figures like VS models, but even I know she is FAR from fat. She has reasonable ,normal tone .You don’t need extreme muscle tone to be healhy. She doesn’t even have cellilite for goodness sake! I don’t understand, Where is she fat? Can you pinch her ?sure However, i see no flab. She has a flat stomach with a tiny waist, reasoanble toend legs and arms. If she is fat then so is beyonce. Has she gaiend weight,duh. Then the list should be named “has… Read more »

Rachel
Guest
Rachel

Ugh, what sort of message do they intend on sending out with lists like that? It’s even more disgusting that they would put someone like her on it. She is by no means ‘fat’. If I was roughly her size, and saw this I would feel awful that I was fat. And If i was bigger than her (which still wouldn’t be fat) I would feel really bad that I was fatter than someone on this list. Sorry, my point has probably been made in the comments above, but I had a sudden urge to put my .02 in about… Read more »

Lynn
Guest
Lynn

Obviously, she looked better before. I would not call her fat though…average comes to mind.

Samantha
Guest
Samantha

What jackass came up with that list, she is gorgeous, always has been!

Babette
Guest
Babette

First off, let me say that Elisha looks absolutely beautiful. At this weight or at any weight. Okay, this IS, as someone said somewhere up there, exactly why we have such **** up perceptions of ourselves. She, Jessica Simpson, and Danielle Fischell (sp) are NOT fat. Are there fat people on that list? Sure, there are, I won’t pull any punches, but to compose a list and to have the nerve to stick Elisha next to “Princess Chunk”, a CAT, is absolutely disgusting. I can speak as someone who was overweight for a good portion of her life and the… Read more »

KarmaChameleon
Guest
KarmaChameleon

First of all, I think the idea of such a list is disgusting whether it’s about fat/skinny/ugly/big nosed/whatever. There’s really no reason for it.

Second of all, I think she looked amazing before and, assuming she was doing it by being healthy and active, still prefer her at that weight. She’s by no means obese now or anything like that but do I think she’s a bit fat? Well, yes. And I think it’s mostly to do with her thighs.

Dayna
Guest
Dayna

Yeah, she clearly put on weight, but I don’t think she should be on a “fat list”…jeeze.

lola
Guest
lola

how mean of some people to say she “deserves to be on a fat list”. Wtf is a fat list anyway?? Thats disgusting. She isn’t fat. She isn’t as tiny as she was, but she doesnt deserve for people to call her fat. For those on here saying she’s fight, I’d like to see you post your pic and show how perfect and cellulite free you are.

Polly
Guest
Polly

Warped world we live in. How can this healthy looking young woman be called “fat”? Kristie Alley is called fat too! If I saw her on the beach, I’d think she was pretty hot.