Leggings Look Better on… Whitney Port VS Hilary Duff!

Black leggings, long white tops and blazers… that’s what Whitney and Hilary were in the mood for this week. Who rocks this outfit? Who looks best in black leggings? Is it skinny Whitney or curvier Hilary?
These 2 girls have been in a very similar competition before – check them out HERE!
So what do you say this time?
Leggings Look Better on… Whitney Port VS Hilary Duff!
Pick your favorite!
5,430 views

































Without a doubt Hilary. She looks sensational here. Personally I think Whitney’s legs are disgusting and so unattractive.
Hilary looks hot in these pictures Whitneys legs are way too skinny and shapeless
Hilary all the way. Muscle tone wins out over skinniness every time for me. I think Whitney’s beautiful but her legs are just too thin.
even though I usualy like how whit’s legs look, i love hillary’s!
she look amazing.
I agree, Hillary does have better legs. However, I would not call Hillary curvy. Just because she has more meat on her bones does not make her curvy. Unlike the other celebs you do call curvy, she does not have an hourglass figure at all- she is more of an upside-down triangle. She has neither hips nor a chest- the only places she gains weight really are her arms, legs, face, and love handles. What does everyone else think?
Yes, you’re right, Hilary is a V shape, not an hourglass. She’s not the epitome of “curvy”, but I think that she does look curvy in certain clothes, especially in some dresses.
I agree she’s not curvy. She looked really squared in a previous post where she was wearing a bandage dress, and most women look curvy in those!
Yeah she’s not curvy but the media tends to use the word as a kinder term than ‘bigger’ ‘fatter’ etc.
To me curvy is someone with a body along the hourglass and pear/spoon shaped lines
Hilary’s an absolute weight chameleon! I personally think she always looks lovely and healthy but there’s no denying that she sometimes looks a little fuller. It just goes to show how good dressing is the key to highlighting your best assets. Cracking legs! xxx
I know! Just the other day their was a post where she looked good, but not this good! Her legs look great! I love the length of Whitney’s legs, it’s hard to choose a favorite.
Without a doubt Hilary! Whitney is way too skinny.
Hilary! Whitney’s legs are wayyyyy too skinny!
Hilary looks amazing here! This outfit is so flattering for her!
Usually I’d pick Whitney 1000 times over anybody because she’s so naturally pretty and fresh ….. however this time I’ll say Hilary looks better.
Skinny jeans and leggings (especially BLACK ones) are not flattering at all when you have chicken legs, sniff!
I’m actually shocked by how slim Hillary’s legs look! Given I thought she had gained from the last few posts, I expected to say Whitney without a doubt, but I’m going to agree with a few posters on here and say I’m changing my mind and goign with Hillary!
hilary looks nothing like the recent pictures of her a little thicker. though they both look great, hilary
hilary looks fantastic! love her look!
is whitney an hour glass, versus? she has thin legs but pretty full thighs. i wud take her as a hourglass. what u thinkk?
Hmm… I think she’s a lollipop (from Trinny & Susannah’s 12 body types, see them here: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-488236/Trinny-Susannah-reveal-12-womens-body-types–you.html) and check out Whitney’s bikini pics here:
http://www.skinnyvscurvy.com/front-and-back/whitney-port-city-bikini.html
Lollipops are usually tall, with very long and thin limbs (many models are lollipops), medium to large busts.
why is everyone so shocked hillarys legs slook slim. hasnt everyone heard by now the slimming effects of black??
and also, trust me, i have skinny legs like whitney and when the muscle is that long, its pretty much near impossible to get muscle definition. it is much easier for shorter ppl because the muscles are shorter and they build easily and quickly. im a gym rat and there is nothing I can do to bulk up my legs. so how bout we comment on things people can maybe change instead of something out of their control.
i doubt whitney doesn’t like her legs. if she didn’t, she wouldn’t always draw attention to them – i.e. v. short dresses and leggings. she probably thinks they’re her best assest.
hilary looks amazing! i never liked whitney’s figure. she looks like a bean-pole and her legs are WAY too skinny to lool attractive. i agree with the other posters. she has chicken legs.
i meant ‘look’ instead of ‘lool’.
I agree with everyone else…Hilary wins big time. She is very pretty and has a nice shape
Hilary LOOKS AMAZING!! she looks sexy yet stilish !
Both look pretty good
I don’t know why, but for some reason I thought was Ashley Tisdale not Whitney. Then I read the caption and I was like, “Ooooh so it is Whitney!” I think both girls have great legs. I like Hil’s face better though
same here i could of swore it was ashley tisdale i stared for quiet some time to make sure
They both have the same ridiculously skinny legs!
ARE U ALL CRAZY……WOW…….AMERICAN CULTURE IS SO DIFFERENT..HERE IN THE CARIBBEAN HAILARY WOULD NEVER BE CONSIDERED CURVY………….ALL I SEE ON THESE 2 GIRLS ARE 2 VERY SKINNY GIRLS…JUS 1 IS SKINNER THAN THE NEXT..I THINK THEY BOTH LOOK LIEK TWIG LEGS…. but its the thruth….
now if u cann kim curvy ..defnately……..hilary…not now.. maybe when she had more meat on her but now.
Haha, I like your culture, really!
Hmm? Poser.
How comes Hilary looks sooo much slimmer here than in her ‘pyjama’ pic the other day. I know black is flattering but still, it’s quite a contrast.
Hilary Duff!! Nooooooooooooo contest!! 8D
hilary for sure….she actually has a shape to her legs!
omg. i usually love whitney but compared to hilary here she…….well she does not compare. hilary looks amazing.
whitney! but they look better on hilary than i thought they would.
I prefer Whitney’s up/down look better. Hilary happens to look great too, but with leggings, Hilary shows bigger thigh muscles and featureless knees…. Whitney wins.
Definitely Hillary. I like muscular and athletic legs.
Hilary seems slimmer than before, right ?!
But she looks great.
they both look good, but hilary just looks amazing here.
Honestly, I like both but I prefer Hilary’s legs on my body.
Both are very beautiful girls.
I’d have to say Whitney without a doubt. She has very nice legs, really her best feature in my opinion. Everyone says Whitney has shapeless legs, but if you look at the pictures, Whitney actually has shape in her legs unlike Hillary. I’d guess you’d have to look at the pictures though.
whitney no diggidy!! Her beautiful long slim legs looks amazing in anything and these black leggings make her look so elegant and slim. HIllary looks fine, but not great when placed next to Whitters.
Hilary of course…She looks really hot in this pic…Whitney’s legs look too thin…
Hilary deffinatly!
the duff by far!