Skinny VS Curvy Battle Time! Jessica Stroup VS Michelle Trachtenberg!
February 17, 2009 in Jessica Stroup, Michelle Trachtenberg, Skinny Versus Curvy Battle by Versus
Jessica and Michelle both attended the same event at Fashion Week – they both wore skintight dresses and I’ve added pictures from 3 different angles to compare them accurately!
You can spot a wide range of differences between these 2: legs’ shape and size, narrow hips vs wider hips, skinny, slightly bony upper body vs a softer appearance overall, different skin tones, different bone structures and on and on.
Let’s vote:
Skinny VS Curvy Battle Time! Jessica Stroup VS Michelle Trachtenberg!
1 more comparison from the front on the second page!
jessica definitly
Michelle looks so hot.
Definately Jessica. Michelle looks very pale and soft.
Jessica looks more confident, I’m pretty sure she thinks she’s very hot but actually Michelle is alot fitter. Jessica would probably have an attractive figure if she were a healthy weight but she’s currently looking painfully thin, whereas Michelle looks soft, healthy and curvaceous, she has a very attractive figure apart from her chunky ankles. In fact Michelle looks naturally pretty facially aswell, doesn’t look like she’d need a great deal of make up to be attractive, Jessica however looks like she’s caked in the stuff.
Michelle is pretty, but she has chunky calves/ankles. Sorry. Jessica is a bit too thin, so tough to say. They are both pretty, though, for sure.
Michelle needs to tone up. Not lose weight, just tone up. Jessica is really thin… a little too thin, but has a gorgeous face.
I’d have to give this to Jessica. I use to like Michelle’s looks, but since her weight gain a few years ago, she hasn’t been the same. Too bad.
they both look pretty good, but if I passed Jessica in the street I’d go, “wow that girl’s pretty skinny.” If I saw Michelle, however, I’d think she was a little bigger than I would like to be, but definitely very pretty with a great butt. Maybe she could do something with her hair though? To Michelle.
Jessica, for that amazingly amazingly beautiful face!
jessica..michelle’s legs are too fat and she is too pale… but i think that michelle has a beautiful face and body i just dont like her legs!…
and in the last picture she looks like scarlett johansson, doesnt she?
Michelle is so beautiful, but she is really soft – like she never does any exercise. Still, for me she is the winner, as Jessica is too small and is making a sexy dress look very unsexy.
Michelle’s got a small waist. I would guess it is a pain in the arse for her to find good jeans with such a difference between her waist size and butt/leg size. She is definitely a pear, and she looks better than Jess, IMO. If Jess weren’t as skinny as she is, it would be a harder choice, but I just can’t go with the person that looks like they are keeping themselves too slim
Jessica!!!!! 100%
Michelle has such big legs….
Why is there such a huge difference between Michelle’s calves in the first picture? The left one looks like it’s almost twice the size of the right one. I guess it’s the angle?
Michelle needs to work out
F***ing idiot. She looks amazing. Whats wrong with you? You probably have an eating disorder anyways, so have fun with that. F***ing dumb ass.
its funny how you hate skinnies so much
but i can understand
fat girls always hate skinny girls
and they can be like soooo furious
right, because I hate all of my skinny friends
I love my own fat ass and jiggly body and think all body types can be gorgeous.
Maybe it’s you(who I assume is skinny) who has a problem with all fat girls.
i agree with you paula, i’d have to say Jessica
I find it kind of unfortunate that I’m picking Jessica. I feel like if I saw Michelle in real life, she wouldn’t look as bottom heavy as she does here, compared to tiny Jessica. Michelle is very pretty, but her body is average, IMO. Jessica is quite skinny, but she looks hot.
Jessica’s look is hotter but she still needs to put on a couple of pounds imo
if you look at michelle’s muscular calf in the first pic, you can guess she does. just different body shape.
wow jessica looks gorgeous.she so sexy and cute.EVerything is so perfect:nice set of legs,tan,face,everything.She is sooo gorgeous.
Michelle has sausage legs.
definantly jessica.
to me, she is flawless.
jessica is very cute and to me, she has a perfect body .
hmm. I never this post. strange
jessica wins this one
*sp : never saw this post
sry:p
michelles ankles are too much so jessica
Jessica hands down.
Jessica no doubt about it
Michelle, because she is beautiful and looks like real women do, who eat.
jessica.
i dont know anyone who would strive to have michelles body. she has cankles
jessica is beautiful. michelle is also beautiful. she isn’t fat, her face and upper body are great (or would be without that hair and that dress) but the legs are a bit unfortunate. i’d have to go with jessica.
by CANKLES! holy shit!!!
michelle wins this one for me.
if jessica gained a few pounds, she’d look great. but these girls are SO freaking thin in real life; they look like skeletons, and that’s not an exaggeration. i live in l.a. and my dad’s in the entertainment industry, so i’ve been very fortunate in getting to see a lot of celebrities, and it’s always amazed me how alarmingly thin they usually are in reality.
Michelle looks like s*** in these pics. The other girl.
wow…she is soo skinny….she got a great figure!
WOW!
Jessica DOES NOT NEED TO LOSE WEIGHT! Michelle is fat! Jessica looks gorgeous
Go jump off a bridge…please?
Man, whats wrong with you people saying Michelle is fat? Like seriously, you people need help. Like man, seriously ??! How in the hell is she fat?!?! Kay, so lets all weigh 50 pounds so we can be skinny.. yayy. Ugh, you people make me soooooo mad! I seriously feel bad for all of you, you people are so messed up. Like, seriously.
Get over it. Like, seriously.
aw i dont even wanna imagine
how f.. i mean big you are..lol
I wish more men would sign up on this site so maybe some of you girls would get it through your heads…bones sticking out is NOT sexy! Its seriously disgusting. It means your not healthy. Curves are sexy man. Like omg. Kay, so that Jessica girl is pretty, yes, but she could stand to gain a few pounds. And Michelle is perfect the way she is.
hate to break it to you ashley.. but Michelle has a TERRIBLE case of cankles. theyre terrifying… FYI.. heterosexual males do comment on this site.. shocking, like the cankles.. yet true.
jessica… LOVE jessica!
Michelle is hot. Especially these days.
D