Beauty & Body Image

Mindy Kaling’s Elle Cover Controversy

mindy-ELLE - Mindy Kaling's Elle Cover Controversy

A while back, Elle Magazine released a few different covers, each featuring  different celebrity: Mindy Kaling, Amy Poehler, Zooey Deschanel and Allison Williams. While the latter 3 ladies all got full-body shots and colorful covers, Mindy got a black and white shot of her face. Various sources and the public started calling the magazine ‘racist’ for giving Mindy a non-colorful cover and said that she was being discriminated against for not having a skinny Hollywood figure. More details from Us Weekly:

Apparently everyone except Mindy Kaling was upset by her Elle cover. The Mindy Project star appeared The Late Show with David Letterman Thursday, Jan. 9, and defended her new magazine photo against her so-called supporters.

“I was for the first time on the cover of a fashion magazine, which is such an awesome, nice thing,” Kaling, 34, told host David Letterman of the controversy. “I saw the cover . . . I thought I look so beautiful. I thought, ‘Wow, I’ve never looked better.’ I feel like I look like a movie star on it.”

Those feelings, however, were not shared by her fans and Elle magazine readers.

“There was a weird reaction which was, ‘Does Elle magazine think Mindy’s not skinny enough to show her whole body like standing up from head to toe?’” Kaling explained. “The sort of implication, what they kept saying was like, ‘What Elle, you can’t put her big fat body on the magazine? Why because she’s just fat and gruesome? Why shouldn’t we look at her beautiful fat body?’”

“And I was like, ‘Okay, people who are trying to defend me,’” the actress quipped. “I just feel like they’re kind of insulting me!”

Kaling was one of four women featured on the cover of Elle’s “Women in TV issue.” Her cover photo, however, was the only headshot rather than almost-full body image used. But the Office alum said she couldn’t be more pleased with how her cover turned out.

“It’s black and white. It looks like I died at my most beautiful,” she joked. “It looks like this is a dead person that they’re like, ‘How could we have taken her away at so young. If only a million dollars for another second with this . . .”

462564673_10 - Mindy Kaling's Elle Cover Controversy

More of Mindy next!

 

450871349_10 - Mindy Kaling's Elle Cover Controversy 450871467_10 - Mindy Kaling's Elle Cover Controversy 462564569_10 - Mindy Kaling's Elle Cover Controversy 462564671_10 - Mindy Kaling's Elle Cover Controversy

elle1 - Mindy Kaling's Elle Cover Controversy elle2 - Mindy Kaling's Elle Cover Controversy elle4 - Mindy Kaling's Elle Cover Controversy

Previous ArticleNext Article
Editor of Skinny vs Curvy Website

Leave a Reply

39 Comments on "Mindy Kaling’s Elle Cover Controversy"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
kia
Guest

well..she’s better full figure with colours

disqus_e5owUDo2KZ
Guest
disqus_e5owUDo2KZ

What?

kia
Guest

she-is-prettier-in-a-coloured-pic-portraying-her-full-figure. please point out what’s wrong with my grammar instead of saying what what what

guest
Guest
guest

what what what

wonderwoman21
Guest
wonderwoman21

It does seem like an odd choice to choose one out of four covers to be the only close up and the only black and white. I wonder what their reasoning is.

I’m subscribed to Elle and enjoy their magazine; especially their perfume samples heh. I would hate this to be a blatant act of racism; though i’m very aware of what is considered beautiful in America (all you have to do is look at the advertisements and who is in it!) and Mindy Kaling isn’t included in it.

Mia
Guest

Most racism these days is not blatant, but rather a series of micro-aggressions. It is racist that our standard of beauty describes White women, or women with ‘European’ features. The editors of vogue may not have done it maliciously, but because they subscribe to European standards of beauty, they may have decided that the black and white photo was the most flattering of the bunch she took. I guess what I’m trying to say is that people can perpetuate racism without being racist, if that makes sense.

CakesOnAPlane
Guest
CakesOnAPlane

so well put! Thank you for contributing a thoughtful and insightful comment to this site.

wonderwoman21
Guest
wonderwoman21

Agree, but I would file this under blatant! The differences are drastic.

I feel like if this was another woman of color who fit the American aesthetic of what’s attractive (thin, narrow nose, lighter skinned) her cover would resemble the other covers; somebody like Kerry Washington or Eva Longoria. But Mindy doesn’t fit that aesthetic because of her weight, features, and darker skin.

Juju
Guest
Juju

” if this was another woman of color who fit the American aesthetic of what’s attractive (thin, narrow nose, lighter skinned)”
There is indeed a double standard, women of color that don’t look too different from the Caucasian aesthetics have more chances to be accepted.

wonderwoman21
Guest
wonderwoman21

Definitely. We see women like Beyonce or Sofia Vergara make it big but we have to realize they both fit into a certain narrow aesthetic. I would love to see Lupita Nyong’o make the cover of People’s ‘Most Beautiful’; not that People is the beacon of American culture but it is a strong commentary of who we’re saying is beautiful. But i won’t hold my breath seeing as People has only put 3 women of color on the ‘Most Beautiful’ cover in the past 20 years (Beyonce, J.Lo, Halle Berry).

MissMarilyn
Guest
MissMarilyn

oh totally agree. Lupita is absolutely stunning and her sense of style is amazing as well. I would be ecstatic to see her on that list!

wonderwoman21
Guest
wonderwoman21

A seriouly gorgeous lady

jello
Guest
jello
Everybody just doesn’t think Elle magazine didn’t do this on purpose, just to start controversy and sell more magazines?! Of course they did. It’s not racist; it is a publicity stunt. Media is their business. Elle knows exactly what they’re doing. Elle knows all of the conversations it’s going to start on the internet (the back and fourth arguments in the comments section); Facebook, here, Buzzfeed, Huffington Post. Elle knows all of the media coverage it’s going to get on Extra, the E Channel, and Access Hollywood and CNN (which is really sad, because there is no way this is… Read more »
wonderwoman21
Guest
wonderwoman21

Maybe, but us peons need something to occupy us!

Grazibel
Guest
Grazibel

Aww poor Mindy. How awful that people are saying that, and that she’s upset by it. The cover photo is so beautiful- I love b&w photos. What if the mag just used that cover because they were playing around with that photo and the b&w coloring is what happened to look best? yeesh. people can be so hypersensitive!

Blair
Guest
Blair

I think it’s a beautiful cover and there’s nothing wrong with it by itself, but it IS strange that it is so different from the other three covers. I think four headshots would’ve been a better move. It is problematic and a bizarre design choice that you have one cover that is not cohesive with the rest of your “Women in TV” collection.

L
Guest

I think all of them are beautiful and mindy does look great but it’s also so obvious when you put the four together that one is not the same at all. The three others are all very similar and then mindys is changed so much that it’s bound to cause contraversy

Magda
Guest
Magda

I like really like her skin. I generally like b&w pics but it does not do her skin tone justice.
Considering her figure, she is thin by my standards. She could have done the cover just like the other girls, who look stunning by the way (Poehler for the win!)

Hazale
Guest
Hazale

Well, her cover DOES look really different from the others. Weird. Don’t know, if there really is a conspiracy behind this.

Hazal
Guest
Hazal

Damn you iPhone. It’s Hazal not Hazale -.-

MerryHappy
Guest
MerryHappy

Honestly, I think hers looks the best hands down. Everyone else is really trying too hard to look ‘come hither’ in their eyes and coy in their bodies, even Amy. And I’m usually team Zooey (I’ve been accused of being her doppelganger, so I’m biased), but that cover is ridiculous.
Mindy’s cover looks glamorous and classy, even if it’s a result of micro-aggressive racism.

PS
Guest

I agree, the funny thing is that no matter the intention Mindy’s cover is the best. The other three look good but so generic, nothing creative or artistic about it, just another Elle, Vogue, anyfashionmagazine cover. So I think Mindy wins two times, because in addition she herself is really happy with the picture!

MerryHappy
Guest
MerryHappy

She looks great. It’s a like a picture a vain person has of themselves blown up on the wall in their living room haha.

Mia
Guest

She actually does look the best. Agreed. I can’t stop staring at the ring she put on her. I love it.

MerryHappy
Guest
MerryHappy

For me it’s the deep v of that dresses neckline. I can’t stop looking at how great her decolletage looks. Think her face looks great too, there’s like a challenge in her eyes along with just looking pretty that makes her face look more compelling.

Calliope
Guest
Calliope

I actually think it’s far more ‘stunning’ and eye-catching than the others. It stands out!

elitairedontcaire
Guest
elitairedontcaire

Funny how Mindy herself thinks the cover is beautiful… Bet those who screamed “racism” the second this cover hit the newsstands are privileged white women from the middle-class.

star77
Guest
star77

I think this cover is far more beautiful than the others! I love black and white photos though. To me this one just seems more unique and stands out more. It sort of has that timeless look to it. Just my opinion. To each their own

MissMarilyn
Guest
MissMarilyn

Good for Mindy for taking the high road and reacting positively! She’s so funny.

I do think it’s odd that out of all four magazine cover they pick the one non-white not-slender woman and change her cover… I mean, even if it doesn’t have anything racist behind it couldn’t the people in charge of Elle be smart enough to realize what it looks like they’re doing??

amelia
Guest
amelia
I actually think Elle paid tribute to her in making her cover a bit different. There is a saying I heard recently in a movie.. it goes something like this.. “why are you trying so hard to fit in.. when you were clearly born to be extraordinaire… ” And I think that applies here. She is by far the most stunning. And by printing her in black and white, it blurs the identification of race/heritage. She looks ethnic.. she could be black, latino, Indian.. middle eastern.. turkish.. greek… etc… or a combination of all. I just don’t understand people who… Read more »
hanan
Guest
hanan

people are used to (body exposure/ sexual image/ temptation) in entertainment world, that if magazines portrait some celebs in non sexual way people get mad ! like what happened with melissa mccarthy “covered picture” on that magazine < it's like female celebs have to strip !!
i just don't get it! especially among "singers", there are too much nudity < you are singer not a p— star.

tequilla
Guest
tequilla

to be honest, her cover is the prettiest one..

disqus_e5owUDo2KZ
Guest
disqus_e5owUDo2KZ

She’s gorgeous. I love her eyes and pretty face shape. I think the cover was beautiful, PERIOD. Not every face can handle such a close-up – and with no hiding behind the hair at that.

solaxia
Guest
solaxia
I think she is beautiful personally. I love that blue dress on her. I can see both sides of the argument…I can see why people get up in arms about only her face being on…there again, who are they kidding, the skinny bodies on the covers are heavily airbrushed too. I can also see Mindy’s point…she was just looking at the cover and being proud of it, because it was almost like an achievement in her eyes…but everyone else was looking deeper than they had to and therefore insinuating things about her body. I just think she has a gorgeous… Read more »
Tonyee
Guest
Tonyee

Not doing a full body shot was VERY calculated and obviously it’s because she is not a ‘slim’ person…That being said, i think her cover being black and white is stunning.

Doing the face shot instead of a full body cover, it is very obvious to see why they did it…but i don’t see the ‘racist’ element.

B
Guest

I just don’t see it as racist. It’d be one thing if they photoshopped her Michael Jackson white, but they didn’t. I think it’s a cool cover. So what if it’s diff than the rest? It looks great.

anonymous
Guest
anonymous

People are so PC about things nowadays. If Mindy doesn’t have a problem with her cover and she likes it then why should anyone else complain?

retrobanana
Guest
retrobanana

hers stands out the most…and I don’t get how its racist and weight discriminating..which one is it? that confuses me..if they are upset about something pick one thing to be upset about…cover looks great im glad mindy was happy shes m girl

Maria
Guest
Maria

God i love, mindy, she is such an awesome person!! Funny, beautiful, and i love that shes curvy <3!

wpDiscuz