Editor of Skinny vs Curvy Website

Leave a Reply

29 Comments on "Knock, Knock! Who’s There?"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Erica
Guest
Erica

At first, I was going to comment the typical “she needs to lose some weight” or “get toned”. But then I realized – she looks fine. She’s in a healthy weight range she’s glowing, and not everyone needs to be a size four or less. Go Amy!

Delilah
Guest
Delilah

Well first of all she’s overweight, period.
But more appropriately for this sight, she looks horrible. What do you expect on a website called skinny vs curvy?

Aga
Guest

Uhm… I highly doubt she is overweight. Can you guys just please stop with your distorted view in female physique? anything BELOW a BMI of 25 is considered NORMAL, and she definitely is. I’m an MD and I’ve seen hundrets of people with some fat but within healthy BMI range.
I would rather say: thanks Amy for being just yourself and setting some real example of being comfortable.

Rachel
Guest
Rachel

As someone who has been chubby, what really surprised me was learning where the line is between normal and overweight. I was barely considered chubby – quite a bit smaller than Amy Schumer is here, in fact – and yet, according to my BMI, I was overweight (BMI of 25.8).

So, yes, she’s undoubtedly overweight.

anna
Guest
anna

Amy is tall, like 5’9″ right? so bmi of 25 is just 169 lbs. You cant see from the front but from the side view I think she’s definitely there.

anna
Guest
anna

not everyone needs to be size four or less or be slim and toned, but I’m pretty sure Amy is considered medically overweight here… she has a bit too much fat to be considered in a healthy weight range. she was fine some time ago, a little chub is harmless, but she’s definitely gained past the healthy range

Guest
Alyssa Mohino

You think her bmi is over 25?

anna
Guest
anna

yes I do, my friend looks quite similar and has repeatedly been told to lose weight by her doctors. Amy just gained more quite recently, she was looking find couple months ago

Kia
Guest

She’s overweight dude

ule
Guest

Dressed like KimK the other day, but actually looks better because it’s less inappropriate for the occasion.

Jason
Guest
Jason

Yikes! She’s always been on the thicker side, but now she’s slowly getting into Lena Dunham season 2 of Girls territory. We got a hot mess situation going on here.

Member
Medusa

My guess was Lena Dunham

Jason
Guest
Jason

Right?! She’s not that far off.

Retrobanana
Guest
Retrobanana

She is just plain fat I don’t care what she says she likes to drink and party and not take care of herself and it shows… to see her with the hot guy in her latest movie looked so unrealistic stop trying to claim she is hot

Antonella
Guest
Antonella

Lol “size 6”

leiabon
Guest
leiabon

Same. Everytime I see her I’m like “and this woman says she’s 1-2 sizes smaller than me?” and then I look in the mirror and I am like “Yeah, no.”

anna
Guest
anna

to be fair she gained quite a bit of weight recently

vossoo
Guest
vossoo

omg all you people are seriously effed up. No wonder women struggle so so much. Luckily, Amy does not have to listen to any of these comments here.
THIS is NOT medically overweight! yes, definitely heavier than average or even “normal”, but far far far away from obese. I estimate an BMI of 24-25. But she is not FAT.

Aga
Guest

Thank you

leiabon
Guest
leiabon

Or maybe the problem are women like her saying they are a size 6 instead of admitting they’re at least a size 10?
I’m 174cm and my weight is 72-73kg. THAT would be around a BMI of 24. Which is normal btw. But she looks heavier than that in comparison.

Guest
Alyssa Mohino

Unacceptable. Women’s bodies MUST conform to the agreed up appearance. Anything outside that is FAT no matter what metric, scientific or other, is used. A woman must be slim, but not muscular. Even if the person is stocky due to being an athlete, that is considered FAT and bmi dies not count.

-some ppl on SvC

aaaaaaa
Guest
aaaaaaa

no one said she is obese. BMI over 25 is technically overweight. obese is much beyond that. I do not believe all women should be thin whatsoever but can’t believe anyone would think she doesnt look overweight from that side picture…

kennedy
Guest
kennedy

me when i let myself go

Sharlane
Guest
Sharlane

SAME

Gold
Guest
Gold

Serious question… Why does she look so bloated all the time? I know she is heavier or whatever, but I know heavier people who don’t look as bloated. Is she on something? Medication? Drink too much? I have a friend who always has this bloated look too and I wonder why.

Taylor
Guest
Taylor

Alcohol, possibly? It definitely leads to bloating/water retention, especially in the face. I’ve noticed a certain “moon face” look to *some* alcoholics.

aaaaaaa
Guest
aaaaaaa

can also be where people gain weight. some just gain in their face after a certain point.

Sharlane
Guest
Sharlane

She’s definitely overweight. This is what I look like when I have a BMI of 26-27. She has decent muscle on her legs which is great but also means she probably weighs more than she even looks… I have a similar stronger-legged build so that’s why I’m thinking BMI 26-27. She’s not “fat” but she’s definitely not at an optimal weight for her height and build.

May
Guest

Amy sporting her average looking body that she all wants us to love for some reason

wpDiscuz